Short answer

A diamond's value rests on the 4Cs: colour (graded D to Z), clarity (Flawless to Included), cut (Excellent to Poor for a round brilliant) and carat weight (one carat is 0.2 grams). A grading report from a laboratory such as GIA or IGI records these grades for a specific stone.

If you are buying a diamond for the first time, or buying many of them for resale, the same four factors apply. They are known as the 4Cs, and they were popularised by the Gemological Institute of America (GIA). This guide explains each one, what a grading report adds and what to ask a seller.

Colour

For a white diamond, colour means how little colour it has. GIA grades it on a scale from D, which is colourless, down to Z, which has a light yellow or brown tint. Grading compares the stone with reference stones under controlled lighting. The differences between neighbouring grades are very small and are easiest to see side by side, so the grade matters most when you are comparing two stones.

Clarity

Clarity describes the tiny natural marks inside a diamond (inclusions) and on its surface (blemishes). The GIA scale has eleven grades, from Flawless to Included 3. Most diamonds sold in jewellery sit in the middle of the scale, where marks are small enough that they are hard to see without magnification. A higher clarity grade is rarer and costs more, but a lower grade is not a defect if the marks do not affect the stone’s appearance or durability.

Cut

Cut is not the shape of the diamond. It is how well the facets are proportioned and polished, and it decides how the stone handles light. For a standard round brilliant, GIA gives a cut grade from Excellent to Poor. The grade considers three things about appearance (brightness, fire and scintillation) and four about design and craftsmanship (weight ratio, girdle thickness, symmetry and polish). A well cut diamond looks lively even if its colour or clarity grade is modest, which is why many buyers treat cut as the factor to protect first.

Carat weight

Carat is a unit of weight, not of size. One metric carat is 200 milligrams, or 0.2 grams, and each carat is divided into 100 points. Price usually rises with weight, and it jumps at round numbers such as one carat and two carats. Two diamonds of the same weight can look different in size and be valued very differently, depending on the other three Cs.

What a grading report adds

A diamond grading report is issued by a gemmological laboratory for one particular stone. It records the grades for colour, clarity and cut, the carat weight and measurements, and whether the diamond is natural or lab-grown. Well known laboratories include GIA and IGI. A report does not set the price, but it gives buyer and seller a shared, independent description of the stone.

When you read a report:

  1. Check that the report number matches the stone. Many laboratories let you look the number up online.
  2. Check the carat weight and measurements against the stone.
  3. Check whether the stone is natural or lab-grown. Lab-grown diamonds are reported differently and use different wording for colour and clarity.
  4. Check which laboratory issued the report. Grading standards differ between laboratories.

A worked example

Imagine two diamonds of the same carat weight. The first has a better colour grade but a lower cut grade. The second has a slightly lower colour grade but an excellent cut. Placed side by side, many buyers find the second stone looks livelier, because the way a diamond handles light depends heavily on how it is cut. This is why price lists that compare only colour and clarity can mislead, and why you should look at all four Cs together.

Shapes and the 4Cs

The cut grade GIA gives applies to round brilliants. Other shapes, such as oval, emerald cut, pear, princess, cushion and marquise, are described by their proportions, polish and symmetry rather than by the same cut grade. If you are buying a shape other than round, ask the seller to explain how the proportions affect its appearance, and compare the length-to-width ratio and the measurements on the report.

Common mistakes

  • Buying on one grade alone. A single grade, such as a high clarity, does not make a diamond better value if the cut is poor.
  • Ignoring the report. Without a report, you rely entirely on the seller’s description.
  • Confusing carat with size. Two stones of the same carat weight can look different in diameter because of how they are cut.
  • Not checking the report number. Check it with the laboratory when you can.
  • Forgetting origin. Check whether the diamond is natural or lab-grown, because the report wording and the market value differ.

Questions to ask a seller

  • Is this diamond natural or lab-grown?
  • Does it have a grading report, and from which laboratory?
  • What are the colour, clarity, cut and carat weight?
  • Is the stone loose or set, and if it is set, can its weight be confirmed?
  • Can I see the report number and check it with the laboratory?

Diamonds on Zarmeera

Zarmeera’s diamond collection clearly labels every diamond as natural or lab-grown, and the maximum size offered is 2 carats. The Certified Diamonds section lists diamonds with a grading report from GIA or IGI, and you can also browse loose diamonds. Prices are not published: add the stones you like to your inquiry list and we reply by email with prices, availability and next steps. To understand the difference between the two kinds of diamond, read our guide to lab-grown and natural diamonds.

Frequently asked questions

What are the 4Cs of diamonds?

Colour, clarity, cut and carat weight. Together they describe a diamond's appearance and are the main factors in its value.

What is a diamond grading report?

A grading report, sometimes called a certificate, is a document from a gemmological laboratory that records the grades and measurements of one particular diamond, such as its colour, clarity, cut and carat weight, and whether it is natural or lab-grown.

How much does a carat weigh?

One metric carat is 200 milligrams, which is 0.2 grams. Each carat is divided into 100 points, so a 0.50 carat diamond is 50 points.

Which of the 4Cs matters most?

It depends on the buyer. Cut strongly affects how lively a diamond looks, carat weight affects its size, and colour and clarity affect how clean and white it appears. Compare stones of the same carat weight on all four, not just one.

Ready to ask?

Prices are not published on this website. Tell us what you are looking for and we reply by email with prices, availability and next steps.

Browse DiamondsSend an inquiry

Keep reading

More from the blog

Your inquiry list

Your list is empty. Press "Add to inquiry" on any piece to start building it.